4 thoughts on “City Still Using Pesticides Despite 2005 Law Banning Them

  1. PART ONE OF THREE

    Thank you Elah Feder and City Limits for raising the important issue of the NY City’s Department of Health granting to itself waivers from the City’s program to limit the use of toxic pesticides in the City.

    The No Spray Coalition, which had won a lawsuit against the City government in federal court in 2005 and achieved a settlement agreement two years later, continues to be appalled by the City government’s annual aerial and truck spraying of pesticides in Staten Island and Queens.

    Areas of New Jersey are also being widely sprayed.

    All mass spraying of pyrethroid and organophosphate pesticides are dangerous to human health (especially to children, the elderly, and those with weakened immune systems), as well as to pets, fish, and other animals. The spraying must be halted immediately.

    Every year, the NYC DOH grants itself waivers from New York City Local Law 37, a law passed in 2005 in response to growing concerns over the health and environmental consequences of mass-spraying of Malathion (and other organophosphates) and Anvil 10+10 (and other pyrethroids, especially those containing the carcinogen Piperonyl Butoxide).

    Only through application and granting of such waivers is the Department of Health enabled to legally conduct the pesticides spraying.

    But the NYC DOH is circumventing the law. It applies for a waiver to itself, and then it grants itself pro forma the right and authority to spray deadly pesticides in NYC. No other agency reviews its application. The checks and balances envisioned in Local Law 37 are thus thwarted, as Elah Feder points out in her article here.

    end Part ONE of THREE

  2. PART TWO OF THREE
    This year’s spray of choice is, once again, Anvil 10+10. It is listed in Local Law 37 as containing piperonyl butoxide and MGK-284. These are “synergists” in Anvil 10+10, and both of these chemicals are classified as possible human carcinogens by the EPA Office of Pesticide Programs. Most products containing pyrethroids continue to be prohibited under LL37.

    Local Law 37 prohibits the use of pesticides by NYC in public places if it contains PBO and/or MGK-264. Why are they violating their own law?

    The No Spray Coalition details the reasons for vacating NYC DOH’s waivers as follows:

    – The City has illegally circumvented Local Law 37’s attempt to protect against health and environmental dangers;

    – The City has entered into a multi-year pattern that misinterprets and misuses the laws forbidding spraying of toxic pesticides on City lands;

    – The City has failed to abide by its own admissions in the Settlement Agreement with the No Spray Coalition et al. in 2007, review the latest scientific research, and participate in discussions with the No Spray Coalition in good faith;

    – The City has failed to evaluate the “public health threat” from pesticide spraying as well as West Nile virus. There has been no Environmental Impact Statement in the last 15 years on which to examine the effects of the spraying;

    – There have been no public hearings in contradiction to the requirements in Local Law 37 and other regulations;

    – The City has repeatedly failed to properly notify the public before spraying pesticides, in violation of Local Law 37 and other regulations, and in violation of the Settlement Agreement;

    – The City has failed to seriously utilize safer alternatives to pesticide spraying;

    – The City has failed to respond in a timely fashion to important questions and concerns from NY
    Assembly member William Colton, and others;

    – The City is illegally spraying toxic pesticides on the people and environment of New York.

    “After years of litigation to stop this reckless spraying of pesticides which has contributed to skyrocketing increases in cancer and asthma, and now the collapse of bee colonies in the New York area, I am outraged that the New York City government is renewing its mindless criminal poisoning of the people and environment of our City,” said Howard Brandstein, coordinator of SOS-FOOD, NY State Against Genetic Engineering, and a plaintiff in the federal lawsuit brought in 2000 by the No Spray Coalition and other organizations against the New York City government’s pesticide-spraying campaign.

    That lawsuit ended in April 2007 when NYC signed a settlement agreement acknowledging, among other stipulations, that pesticides:

    a) may remain in the environment beyond their intended purpose

    b) cause adverse health effects

    c) kill mosquitoes’ natural predators (such as dragonflies, bats, frogs, birds)

    d) increase mosquitoes’ resistance to the sprays, and

    e) are not presently approved for direct application to waterways.

    The Department of Health contravenes that settlement by now stating that there are no significant risks of adverse impact to human health associated with the proper use of this product. That is simply a baldfaced lie.

    In fact, the spraying puts many New York City residents and visitors at grave risk. “These kind of ignorant and lying politicians and bureaucrats apparently have no problem destroying our health in order to ‘save’ us from the so-called West Nile virus,” Howard Brandstein added.

    “Clearly, the spraying jeopardizes a thousand times more people than the disease.”

    The pesticide the City is spraying — “Anvil 10 + 10 — belongs to a class of adulticides known as pyrethroids, which are endocrine disruptors. They mimic hormones such as estrogen, and may cause breast cancer in women and drastically lower sperm counts in men. Pyrethroids have also been associated with prostate cancer, miscarriages and preterm delivery, asthma, toxicity to many vital organs including the nervous system, liver, kidneys and the gastro-intestinal tract, skin rashes, itching and blisters, and nausea and vomiting.

    Anvil contains the cancer-causing chemical piperonyl butoxide, which the Environmental Protection Agency lists as a suspected carcinogen. It also contains Sumithrin — a synthetic toxin (NOT a naturally occurring pyrethrin), made in the laboratory — as well as benzene-related chemicals (which the label calls “inert ingredients.”)

    Thousands of New Yorkers are severely sickened by the spraying every year, but they go unrecorded and unreported. Several members of the No Spray Coalition, including two of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit, died from pesticide-related illnesses. Many suffer from Multiple Chemical Sensitivities (MCS) or Asthma
    caused or exacerbated by the spraying.

    The City administration must be made to understand that pesticides are extremely dangerous to human health as well as to the natural environment, and have long-term consequences.

    The No Spray Coalition strongly urges the City to stop pesticide spraying immediately, reconsider its entire approach, and seek alternative, safe means to control mosquitoes. There are natural, safe ways for each person to ward off mosquitoes. The City should not be poisoning the entire population.

    We call on the Mayor and City Council to hold the DOH in violation of the intent of Local Law 37 and other laws, and of the Court-mandated “Settlement Agreement” with the No Spray Coalition, et al., and urge City officials to stop the spraying NOW. Please protect the residents and visitors to New York and the natural environment from the extremely dangerous, unnecessary, ineffective and illegal mass spraying of toxic pesticides.

    Stop spraying now. Stop poisoning people, animals and the environment.

    Mitchel Cohen
    Coordinator, No Spray Coalition

    END TWO of THREE

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *