Share This Article
“When he was running for mayor, Mr. Mamdani said he’d work on collecting fines the city was owed as part of finding funding for policy proposals like universal childcare. The time is here.”


Many times over many years, I have pointed out—to mayors, the City Council, state elected officials, at Charter Commission and city agency hearings, community board and Civic Association meetings, even in letters to editors—that there are hundreds of millions in unpaid Department of Buildings and Environmental Control Board (DOB/ECB) fines. I found this out via freedom of information requests to the City’s Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH) several years ago. Nothing has been done.
With the recent, tragic building collapse on Brooklyn’s major Flatbush Avenue attracting so much attention, perhaps it’s finally time to wake up.
In fact, there is this clause in NYC’s Charter chapter 45A, re. “Environmental Control Board” section 1049-a(d) (1)(i): “A judgment entered pursuant to this paragraph shall remain in full force and effect for eight years.” I have argued for its repeal—finding that many officials are unaware of it.
I have not been able to find out exactly when, how and why this sentence came to be in the City Charter. Keep in mind that real estate developers are prime donors to campaigns for candidates running for city and state office. Indeed, imagine a candidate for, say City Council, asking developers for campaign contributions one day and the next introducing a bill to collect on their long-overdue violations?
If you check the city’s Buildings Information Systems site and enter the address of a building with a history of violations, you are bound to come across the phase “written off” for fines levied more than eight years ago, even where a dangerous condition existed.
While recognizing that real estate development is an important sector, and does contribute to the economy in many ways, I submit that it should not hold so much influence that it is able to control elected officials in order to get whatever it wants—or ignore “Stop Work Orders” at construction sites.
While more affordable housing clearly is needed, I have seen Brooklyn neighborhoods become unaffordable with the creation of high-end condos and “starter castles” (a term borrowed from former City Councilman Tony Avella when he visited us).
Whether it’s former Mayors Bill de Blasio’s Mandatory Inclusionary Housing (MIH) and Zoning for Quality and Affordability (ZQA) or Eric Adams’ “City of Yes” initiatives, they actually are developer dreams. Ask homeowners and you’d learn that the initiatives do nothing for preserving the character and safety of neighborhoods.
So, now my question: will the attention to and investigation of this Flatbush building collapse force Mayor Zohran Mamdani, the City Council, along with NY State Assembly and Senate oversight committees, to finally push the City’s Department of Finance to stop making excuses and aggressively pursue owed fines, and the Department of Buildings to assure that accompanying violations are fully addressed?
Furthermore, besides—very importantly—trying to prevent more avoidable tragedies like this building collapse, imagine adding nearly hundreds of millions to the city’s budget?
After all, when he was running for mayor, Mr. Mamdani said he’d work on collecting fines the city was owed as part of finding funding for policy proposals like universal childcare. The time is here.
Ed Jaworski is president of the Madison-Marine-Homecrest Civic Association and co-founder of the Brooklyn Neighborhood Congress.